Thinking Critically About Firefly: Serenity (Episode 1)

Serenity is a great pilot episode for a couple of reasons. For one thing, it's just a damn entertaining episode. More important, though, it shows us that Whedon and friends knew exactly who these characters were from day one. For better or worse, that means that there's a lot to recognize in the episode in terms of setting up of characters, style, and conflicts. As such, this is going to be a long post, possibly longer than the double that the episode length already demands. So, let's get going and start at the very beginning.

The opening sequence, the ending of the Battle of Serenity Valley, is a bit of a red herring -- its scale and its style are unlike anything else the series has to offer. I'd call this a blessing, ultimately, as the scene shows that the effects budget can in no way support this kind of high action, large scale, future combat; but it serves its primary purpose well in showing a Mal who is ultimately not the same Captain Reynolds we know and love and letting us see clearly what is responsible for the change that takes place.

The Mal we see here is an optimist. He believes that the just nature of his cause will see him through to victory if he, and his men, can remain dedicated to it. I know many people who have missed this, but he also shows himself to be a man of faith, not only in his rhetoric about angles and "The Hot Place", but also in a very important shot of him kissing the cross around his neck. The Battle of Serenity Valley is responsible for Mal's loss of faith, but not just in God, who failed him in time of need, despite all of his efforts to follow what he saw as the right path. The battle is also responsible for Mal's loss of faith in human institutions, even if he manages to maintain belief in human individuals. His superiors in the Independents abandoned him, too, even though everything seemed to be going so right. The result is a Mal who only trusts himself and his crew. The scene also establishes many of the most beloved elements of the Mal who is, though: chiefly the ability to command the loyalty of those around him.

I remember watching this episode for the first time, I was intrigued after that first scene; but the scene that follows -- the deep space salvage on the destroyed cargo ship -- was what made me fairly certain I'd love this series. There were two reasons: first, the introduction of Wosh and the universally adored dinosaurs. Second, the Crybaby. Wosh lived up to expectations, but the Crybaby has always remained a marker of what could have been. The absolute cleverness of it as a cheap, low tech, but effective tool gave me high hopes for other ways that these Desperate Men would find their way out of tricky situations. For better or worse, though, it was, at least in part, one of a kind. Certainly, we got plenty of other glimpses of how the collective creativity of the crew helped them get out of tough scrapes, but none of them excited me as much as the Crybaby did on that first viewing.

One final side-note about this scene: I really don't like the Jayne, "Let's moon 'em" shot (or line). I get that it's supposed to be his brief character establishing moment, much like Wosh's dinosaurs or Kaylee's getting stuck in the engine room; but it doesn't work for me. It may be the way in which it's inserted into the rest of the footage, but I've never been a fan.

From here we get our first brief glimpse of one of the two major types of scenes that take up most of the series: on-ship interaction between the crew. And the bits of dialog here are pitch perfect for setting up much of what's to come in this regard. We see Mal keeping the crew somewhat in the dark -- ostensibly to keep them from worrying. We see Kaylee being incurably cheerful. We see Wosh struggling with the fact that Zoe will always be as loyal to Mal as she is to him. The scene that follows, on Persephone, gives us an equally brief glimpse at the other sort of major sequence: on-the-job interactions. The conversation with Badger shows us the calm, controlled nature of Mal's interaction with those not of his crew; and it shows the good-luck bad-luck balance that defines so much of the lives of the crew of the Serenity. It also serves to establish the character of Book and to show the living conditions of the huddled masses, even on a "civilized" planet like Persephone.

Final notes on the Persephone scene: In his readiness to deal with Patience, we see the extent to which Mal is willing to risk himself to preserve the lifestyle of himself and his crew. We get some great Mal and Zoe banter back on the ship. Finally, we have our first of many instances of incredibly poorly pronounced Chinese. Look forward to those.

As we greet the new passengers, we get a nice, slightly misleading introduction to Simon, our first shots of Mal and Inara fighting and of Kaylee fawning over Simon, and a blunt portrayal of Mal's discomfort with religion (contrasted with his insistence on respect and decency). Again, lots of setting up of group dynamics happening, and all of it done well. The old relationships feel believably old and the new ones seem like they're developing naturally. All tied in we get a nice little bit of universe establishment around the dinner table so we know what the deal is with all of these colonies. Following dinner, we get a Book-Inara scene that could have been incredibly painful as we establish their mutual fascination with Mal (one borderline romantic, one purely personal). If I were just to read the script here, it would seem incredibly forced -- the epitome of telling instead of showing -- but Mal has been so firmly established as fitting their descriptions of him, and Morena Baccarin and Ron Glass have a very nice chemistry together as the two outsiders on the ship, that the scene works rather nicely and sets the stage well for the many future conversations between the two.

Leading into the end of the first half of this double episode, we finally get to the start of the series' major source of tension: Simon and River's flight from the Alliance (which adds urgency to Mal and company's own desire to stay out of the spotlight). The reveal is built into a great scene in which we see Book's willingness to punch out the law-man who shoots Kaylee (the first sign that he's been more than a Shepard at some point in his life), Zoe's willingness to pull a gun to keep Jayne in line (the first sign that he's been trouble before and will be again), the depths to which Simon is willing to sink to stay away from the feds (though we don't yet know why), and the crew's intense protectiveness of Kaylee (who represents all of their innocence to some degree or another). Finally, we get to that great would-be-end of the first episode, Mal's mighty, confused, "huh".

This is all followed in the beginning of the second half by a lot of mildly unfortunate telling about River. In her current state, and in the current confines, there's no good way for them to establish River's brilliance and athleticism, so Simon needs to tell us all about it along with how she was taken and, presumably, experimented on and the lengths he went to to save her. It's handled gently, as a loving brother speaking tenderly of the little sister he's sacrificed everything to protect. Because of this, it works better than it might have; though I'm not convinced that his speech needed to be so long. After all of this and the crew debate as to the proper course of action, we get a nice Jayne scene as he interrogates Lawrence Dobson, the Alliance law-man, and is made an offer we can't tell if he'll refuse. This is quickly followed by our first brief encounter with Reavers -- the cannibalistic bogeymen who will pop up from time to time throughout the rest of the show's run.

As we find out that Kaylee is okay, coupled with a hilarious if evil prank on Simon by Mal, the episode kicks into gear for its remainder as the deal with Patience is finalized and the job on Whitefall begins. We see Mal doing his best to be reasonable and fair, looking to avoid trouble and get paid and still going through with the job even when he knows that there's an ambush in store. Cleverness again comes into play as Mal, Zoe, and Jayne prepare for the job, not only disarming trap but turning it around (and making it look like Jayne may have taken law-man Dobson up on his offer). Speaking of Dobson, he's broken free, beating Book more than necessary in the process and abducting River. Trouble aplenty brewing now!

As the deal with Patience goes south as predicted, Mal, Zoe, and Jayne all show their skills. They kill Patience's men while leaving her alive and claiming their payment (and leaving the supplies, as originally agreed). Simon manages to briefly get the upper hand on Dobson as he desperately struggles to continue protecting his sister, and the Reavers show back up as the crew prepares to flee the planet. Mal, Zoe, and Jayne arrive back at the ship, distracting Simon and letting Dobson reclaim his prize. Now deadly serious, Mal shows his willingness to do what's necessary and defuses the Dobson situation with a single bullet as he boards. Wosh, an injured Kaylee, and Book, who once again shows he's more than he seems, work in coordination to pull off an elaborate maneuver, a Crazy Ivan, and escape the Reaver's clutches. Sweet victory!

Finally, a nice bit of falling action as Inara and Book get more chance to talk about the unique facets of life on Serenity and Mal convinces Simon that the best way to keep his sister safe is to stay on as medic and the first episode of Firefly is over. It's a damn shame that Fox didn't air this episode first, even as a two-parter, as it's the best introduction to the series I can possibly imagine. I feel like I may have delved too deeply into synopsis here, but there was a lot of setup to do, both for me and the episode. Future reviews ought to be shorter and focus more on specifics (along with a brief plot overview). Unfortunately, the next two episodes aren't quite up to snuff. I don't particularly dislike The Train Job or Bushwhacked, but I'd probably put them both in my bottom five episodes. We'll power through those, though, and get to the delightful second disk, which gives us Shindig, Jaynestown, and Our Mrs. Reynolds, over the course of the next week or two. Thanks for reading.